Is creativity jeopardized in the data-driven advertising industry?

Is creativity jeopardized in the data-driven advertising industry?

< Back to Articles | Topics: Trends

This is a guest post from ZIA Creative Network Inc.
(Member since 2020)


Waseem Yakdi
CEO, Zia Creative Network INC.

I feel nostalgic and envy for an era I couldn’t witness, a time when creative work was printed out on solid boards and stood to people’s attention. But who knew if the billboard was successful in selling Coca-Cola? Or if the print ad really moved the needle in convincing people to buy a Jaguar over a Mustang.

There was actually no way of knowing. And by not knowing, ad men like Don Draper could continue to sell their performance and sell the creative that may not have necessarily driven sales. But that may have instead stimulated the imagination of the people.

In today’s digital-paced world, data makes the rules, which is why brands are increasingly turning to tech-enabled advertising agencies. Before the advent of social media and digital marketing, there was a mystery attached to every ad campaign that offered no measurement of sales conversion.

But today, this mystery ended as social media insights tell exactly which handbag is sold to which 25-year-old female with an interest in shoes. But are those metric-driven campaigns giving creativity enough space to breathe?

Advertising agencies know very well catchy content can prove to be the most effective, but they also cannot ignore the fact that they are in the business of selling things for their clients. With the pressure on clients to hit numbers, it becomes difficult to play when you’ve got a babysitter over your head telling you not to muck around.

A big challenge facing creative agencies today is to convince their clients that it’s worth taking a punt. Another problem is when the agencies are willing to push the boundaries, and the client says it’s a bit too creative.

In this age of austerity, agencies have to find a balance between sales and creativity. To abandon out-of-the-box ideas just because they’re not supported by statistics is folly. This severely limits the value we as agencies can bring to our clients.

I am not against data, but a substantial weight must be given to instincts. The instincts of smart and creative people, supported by strategic reasoning, can do wonders for the brands.

Today, we’re scared of taking risks when it comes to ideas. Risky creative, previously considered paramount, is now seen through the lens of fear. In the world of unrelenting competition, it has become an uphill battle for creativity where it’s finding ways to survive in the data-driven money game. Data has become an easy shield to hold up while taking risky business decisions. The “what ifs” by the devil’s advocates often overpower great ideas.

Digital space has taken center stage in the advertising industry. Brands aren’t losing time in taking advantage of statistics in creating scroll-stopping ads. Ones that stand out and capture the audience’s attention in a social media landscape already flooded with constant posts on the news feeds.

Undoubtedly, creativity is required to engage with the audience. But data analysis can help creatives understand their target audience in a way that seems almost magical. Some view this as a barrier to creative freedom though.

Whether you buy a rectangular ad on a local newspaper or take over a homepage on YouTube, you initially need to get the right message delivered to the right person. Then the format enables the creativity.

With the right mindset, plus a fresh and more creative approach, brands can use data to do work that doesn’t just get the attention of customers but captures it, holds it and keeps them wanting more.

We must not forget we’re not in the era of the 50s or 60s anymore. Fortunately, now we can strike a happy balance between knowing our audience, trusting our gut and intuition, and taking a risk. It is crucial to ensure your data is the fuel igniting the creative spark, not the flood that extinguishes it.

Going digital has become imperative for brands to connect with customers, increase brand awareness and skyrocket revenue. There is a paradigm shift from traditional ad spend to digital.

We see major advertisers are experiencing a steady decline in traditional media, but overall marketing budgets have increased. In such a scenario, there is a soaring demand for agencies with cutting-edge digital expertise and unprecedented creativity skills. Brands have become extremely cautious in picking an agency whose credibility is largely based on both creativity and digital ability.

Check out ZIA Creative Network's array of advertising and marketing services here.

< Back to Articles | Topics: Trends

Stay Connected

Subscribe to our weekly e-newsletter and receive important updates on Halifax Chamber events, Member benefits and advocacy news.

Need recovery support?